1886-1888-Father Julien
1888-1889-Father R.A. Wenzel
1889-1899-Father William McLaughlin
1899-1920-No pastor (St Vincent's was a mission church
from St Patrick's, Chatham)
1920-1925-Father McDonnel-1st resident pastor
1925-1928-Father Thomas F. Morrissey, Ph.D.
1928-1934-Father Matthew Toohey
1934-1939-Father Francis J. Doogan
1940-1945-Father John J. Duggan
1945-1953-Father Matthew J. Sharkey
1953-1954-Father John E. Hewetson
1954-1966-Father Thomas H. Murphy
1966-1971-Father Francis X. Dennehey
1971-1979-Father Joseph Ferrito
1979-1992-Father Peter J McHugh
1992-2010-Monsignor Patrick E Brown
2011-2024 Father A. Richard Carton
2024-Present Father Hernan Cely
1933 -Father Aloysius S. Carney
Father Benedict W. Howe
Father Thomas F. McHugh
1935- Father Joseph A. Carroll
Father Michael C. Zarrillo
1938-Father Matthew Sharkey
1953-Father Eugene McQuaid
1961-Father Edward Ruddy
1964-Father Pius Janowski, CAP
1970-Father John Klein
1971-Father Robert M. Diachek
1975-Father Frank D'Andrea
1981-Father William Stober